The
Land of Many Names
Towards
a Christian understanding of the Middle East conflict
REVIEWS
CHRISTIAN HERALD 7/6/03 "The book has a number of strengths. It is written
in an agreeable style which is accessible to the non-specialist. At the same time,
Maltz manages to pack a lot of information into this modest volume. His efforts
to inform his readership of different ways of reading sacred texts is commendable.
Furthermore, Maltz articulates the Christian Zionist perspective in a very succinct
and skilful manner … It is to be hoped that Maltz' contribution to the debate
will be read, not shunned, by those taking the opposite viewpoint". Peter
Riddell, Director of the Centre for Islamic Studies at London Bible College CHRISTIANITY+RENEWAL
August 2003 "This book lives up to the blurb in its style - lively, entertaining
and provocative - it gives a well-researched and popular account of Israel's history
from the days of Abram to Sharon … Addictive, dented some of my convictions and
made me think hard" Tony Sargent, Principal of International Christian College,
Glasgow PROPHECY
TODAY September/October 2003 "This author is gifted in presenting the complex
historical issues in an erudite yet understandable way … I recommend this book"
MESSIANIC TESTIMONY
magazine Summer 2003 "A comprehensive overview in a very readable, almost
conversational way." JOY
MAGAZINE (Assemblies of God) September 2003 "I found this book a good read
… I was challenged and ultimately persuaded by his thesis"
POINTERS MAGAZINE August 2003 "It is the best factual book about Israel
that I have read for a long time … This is a very good buy and definitely one
that I am grateful for" C
L PUBLICATIONS (Chris Hill) "Steve Maltz has written this very helpful
book in a light and readable style, yet at no point is it less than well researched,
cogently argued and biblically balanced." DIRECTION
MAGAZINE (Elim Pentecostals) December 2003 "I can't over-emphasise the
importance of this book by Steve Maltz ... He gives a very balanced overview of
the Christian's understanding of the present-day Middle East conflict." 'Steve
Maltz has an evident gift for explaining complex historical issues in a simple
and conversational manner, and he is to be commended for such an easily read and
yet comprehensive overview of this vital period. Christians and non-Christians
alike are urged to read and then rethink this whole matter.' Derek White,
Founder, Christian Friends of Israel 'I
believe that this book is long overdue and will challenge all who read it to recognize
that God is alive and active in Israel and with the Jewish people. Steve Maltz
argues his case well. It's guaranteed to provoke - it's meant to!' Julia
Fisher, writer and broadcaster
"This is a helpful book to dispel some of the myths and prejudices about
Israel today" Tony Pearce, Light for Last Days "I
like it. For the ones who just don't know it could prove useful, as it does address
issues in a fairly simple and logical way" Roy Thurley, Director Christian
Friends of Israel SOME
COMMENTS ON EARLIER DRAFTS OF THE BOOK "I
enjoyed much of what you wrote. I was also sympathetic with much of what the book
said" Willy Mackenzie, Christian Focus Publications “I
think you've got a good, lively style, and have pitched it at the right level
for the intelligent but uninformed reader … " David Moloney, Hodder & Stoughton
“Clearly you know
how to write. The book is engaging and you interact with the reader. You cover
complex and complicated material swiftly and concisely. It is clear you have done
a lot of research.” Andy Peck, assistant editor Christianity+Renewal magazine "I
think you have a good subject and a cheerful, engaging style which dispels a lot
of the confusion surrounding the Promised Land. I hope it does really well."
Tony Collins, Monarch Publications A
GRUDGING COMMENT FROM DAVID PAWSON(who
also suggested that there was not enough Bible exposition!) "You
have produced a useful compilation of historical information and evidence which
I hope will attract and impress the readers you have in mind."
PREFACE
In May 2002 I helped
to man a stand at the Christian Resources Exhibition in Esher, Surrey.
Folk from 21 different ministries were exhibiting under the banner
Why Israel? and seeking to open dialogue with other Christians,
whatever their background or perspective. Interestingly, my overriding
impression from those four days was that the only people willing
to discuss the matter were those who shared the viewpoints of the
exhibitors. The folk at the Rediscovering Palestine stand
observed similar behaviour.
This spoke volumes
to me of the vast rift between those who are generally for Israel
in the current conflict and those who aren't. It was not dissimilar
to the family who see the Christian evangelists at the front door
and hide behind the sofa, hoping they haven't been spotted through
the window. They think they know what the visitors are going to
say, they've heard it all before and they're not willing to start
a fresh argument on the subject. 'Why don't they leave us alone?'
is the cry. Yet you and I know that hiding your head in the sand
is not the best answer when truth, and in this case eternal salvation,
is at stake. The trouble is that this family doesn't know it!
Tragically we Christians
can be ignorant of our own blind spot, our unwillingness to see
the other point of view. One side would stress that Christians should
pursue justice and righteousness and, as with apartheid in South
Africa, should side with those whom they see as the oppressed and
downtrodden, the Palestinians. Others, equally motivated by the
Bible, would agree in principle, but would stress God's integrity
and faithfulness in terms of Old Testament covenants in relation
to the land as God's promise to the Jews. How can there be such
a division between Christians on such a vital issue?
How many times have
you been approached by someone and asked the question 'So what do
you think about what's happening in the Middle East?' How frustrated
have you been in your inability to string together a few coherent
words, let alone a solid, robust argument to support your views?
You are not alone. Hours of study and a PhD are the minimum requirements
here for a full understanding of the intricacies and subtleties
of a situation that doesn't even have a history people can agree
on!
No issue has split
the Christian world more than the Israel/Palestine conflict, yet
there is no current issue as confusing. Millions of words have been
written and spoken about it, but how much of it has truly sunk in,
how much of it has made sense, how much of it has been untainted
by personal opinion or editorial slant? Jews and Zionists will tell
you one thing and Arabs and Arabists will tell you the opposite!
Surely they can't both be right, surely there can only be one truth,
one set of proven historical events that can unravel the whole mess?
Unfortunately it isn't that straightforward. The situation is so
complex, puzzling and emotionally charged that it is well-nigh impossible
to get an objective viewpoint - it is exceedingly difficult to find
historical sources with no axes to grind, commentators who could
be accepted as truly impartial.
Even now you have probably
got an idea of where I'm coming from and, if you haven't, I'll give
you a little clue: I am an English Jew who discovered Jesus, my
Messiah, some 16 years ago. This makes me biased, yes? No, because,
for a Christian, the truth must always come first, despite the consequences.
So the signature verse for this book is:
'God is spirit,
and his worshippers must worship in spirit and in truth' (John
4:24).
Nothing is more important
than absolute honesty in our worship, in how we present ourselves
to God, in all our thoughts and actions. Being true to the Spirit
who indwells us is paramount, and a vital part of this is our quest
for the truth in all situations.
I ask you not to judge
me before you have read what I have to say. Instead feel free to
judge me by the fruits of what you do read. If you are left with
a deeper understanding of the heart of God, a new commitment to
prayer and a new, or refreshed, love for both Jewish and Palestinian
people, then the fruit is good. My earnest desire is to understand
God's truth about the situation in the Middle East and then to share
it with others. There can only be one truth, one authentic script
for the ongoing drama. The time is coming when we will all have
to take a stand on this key issue and I hope that this book will
provide a useful signpost for you.
With regard to the
subject of this book, people tend to fall into three groups: those
who believe that Israel has in some way a divine mandate; those
who believe that Israel has no divine mandate in any way; and those
who haven't got a clue about the matter because people in the other
two groups seem equally persuasive. This book has been written for
all groups, to clear away the cobwebs and to provide you with sufficient
information for an informed opinion on the subject.
If, having read this
book, you are still confused, then I have failed. If, having read
this book, you are not spiritually invigorated and challenged, I
have also failed. This is a hot topic. God doesn't want you to be
lukewarm; He wants people to be His witnesses, not just to other
Christians but to the world out there that has absolutely no clue
what is going on and has no Rock to hold on to. What better way
to introduce people to this Rock than to show them exactly who is
in charge of a world situation that, humanly speaking, has no
workable solution?
INTRODUCTION
Let's be clear about
this now. Israel is a little place, about the same size as Wales.
Surrounded by thousands of miles of oil-rich desert, it is populated
by a vast, seething melting pot of different colours, cultures and
cuisines. It's the holiest place for great religions whose scriptures
argue against having holy places! It has a geography of extremes:
snow-capped mountains in the north, lush green orchards in the west,
barren desert in the south and the lowest place on Earth in the
east! It is possible to start a car journey needing an overcoat
in Jerusalem and be sunbathing an hour later by the Dead Sea! Can
Wales boast all of that?
It's also the world's
foremost political and religious hotspot, giving rise to more United
Nations resolutions than all other nations put together! It's both
hated and loved by more people than any other. It's the most fascinating,
mysterious and intriguing place in the world. It is also the most
misunderstood and confusing place. Its history is a murky web of
truth, half-truth and no-truth, depending on your perspective and
allegiance. Its very name provokes dissent. To Jews it is Eretz
Israel, the Land of Israel. To most Arabs it is Palestine. To many
Christians, confused by the whole issue, it is the simple fudge
of the Holy Land. >
The world has changed
a great deal since the end of the Second World War. The Cold War
came and went as Eastern Europe passed from repression to liberation.
Two superpowers became one and Britain more or less lost her empire.
The rest of Europe has voluntarily unified, by mutual consent rather
than by Nazi domination. Populations moved eastwards and westwards
and northwards and southwards, driven by war or deprivation. No
continent has been unaffected by this mass movement of people.
Yet in one slip of
land, a mere green and gold scar in the deserts of Araby, time has
frozen. People are still arguing and killing each other over events
that happened more than 30, 40, 50 years ago. The year 1948 provokes
contrasting emotions for the people of the land - to Jews it was
liberation from 1,900 years of persecution, to Arabs it was the
Nakba, the catastrophe.
This book deals with
the origins of the current crisis in Israel. It has been written
to help you in your understanding of what is a very thorny but vital
topic for the Church today. Starting with the earliest Bible promises,
it includes a history of the land from biblical times through to
the modern day. Finally there is a summing-up and a look to the
future, with the Bible and its promises as our reference.
It is my belief that
we Christians must look beyond day-to-day politics and realise that
the conflict is a spiritual conflict. The sooner we begin
to look at it through spiritual eyes, the sooner we will wake up
to the realities of the battles being fought in heavenly realms.
These are exciting times, frightening times.
PROLOGUE
The best way to approach
a subject as emotive as this is to put one's cards on the table
right at the start, so that there can be no misunderstandings or
suspicions. To be as frank as I can, this is an attempt at a response
to books that claim to represent 'different theological perspectives'
but tend to lean towards just one particular perspective. In fact,
of the 12 contributors to one such book, 11 are in basic
agreement that the promises of God to Abraham concerning the 'Promised
Land' have now been inherited by the Church and that the State of
Israel is nothing more than a blip of modern history.
Do we, as Christians,
go with the flow and play it safe? Do we follow the majority view
just because this is taught in many Bible colleges and theological
schools in the UK? The impression seems to be that a good dose of
'formal biblical and theological study' provided at these establishments
will put you right on this issue and clear your mind of such nonsense
as the restoration of Israel!
Does this mean that
the majority of us who have not had the benefit of a formal Christian
education do not have the tools to read the Bible correctly? Does
this mean that only theologians are properly equipped to deal with
such thorny issues as the identity of Israel and the Church? Does
that mean that there's no point in consulting the Bible (particularly
the Old Testament) on these matters, because we will probably get
it wrong? Do we ordinary Christians not have a duty to examine the
issues for ourselves? Also, how do these educational establishments
arrive at their theological position? In other countries, notably
the USA, the majority of schools would take a totally different
perspective. Are we not all studying the same Bible?
These are good questions
to ask because there is a lot at stake. Although these issues are
not as vital as one's personal salvation, they are important for
many reasons, not least concerning the faithfulness of God in His
dealings with His people. Therefore it is essential that every Christian,
whatever their educational background, should prayerfully seek the
truth on such a key issue. There is no sitting on the fence here;
there can only be one truth.
In August 2002 a group
of evangelical Christians in the USA sent a letter to President
Bush expressing their concern at what they saw as imbalance in American
policy towards the Middle East conflict. One statement they made
is worthy of note: 'Significant numbers of American evangelicals
reject the way some have distorted biblical passages as their rationale
for uncritical support for every policy and action of the Israeli
government instead of judging all actions - of both Israelis and
Palestinians - on the basis of biblical standards of justice.'
When we get to the stage where Christians openly accuse others of
'distorting biblical passages' it is time for us to truly seek God's
face and examine how there can be such a split in the Body of Christ.
The arena of conflict
is the cauldron of confusion known as hermeneutics, which, for you
and me, is concerned with how we should read and apply the Bible.
The two key skirmishes are, firstly, how much of the Bible should
be taken literally and, secondly, to what extent do we read the
Old Testament in the light of the coming of Jesus in the New Testament.
The trick is getting the balance right between these two factors
and it is fair to say that the differences of opinion are caused
by different emphases being given to each of them.
One barrier to the
acceptance of a pro-Israel view in the UK is our natural conservatism,
a fear of being sucked into what is viewed by some as the 'lunatic
fringe'. Interpreting some key scriptures in a certain way is not
necessarily going to turn you into a full-blown extreme dispensationalist
or end-time fanatic, leafing through one of the hundreds of books
on the subject for clues to the prophetic apocalyptic timetable.
One must not be ruled by such fears and you should trust yourself
with a certain degree of discernment. Don't throw the baby out with
the bathwater. Be real. We should be secure enough in our views
to defend them to anyone.
It is all a matter
of personal integrity. Be yourself. Be blessed.
CONTENTS
Preface
Introduction
Prologue
Chapter 1: Canaan
Chapter 2: The Land
of Milk and Honey
Chapter 3: Israel and
Judah
Chapter 4: Judea and
Samaria
Chapter 5: Palestine
Chapter 6: The Holy
Land
Chapter 7: Zion
Chapter 8: Israel
Chapter 9: The 'Zionist
Entity' and the West Bank
Chapter 10: The Promised
Land?
Epilogue
|